top of page

T20 WC 2024: Challenges India's management will have to address in absence of Impact Player rule

T20 World Cup 2024: How will Rahul Dravid and Rohit Sharma manage the mindset shift from Impact Player rule from IPL 2024?

T20 WC 2024: Rohit Sharma, Rahul Dravid to work together on mindset change from IPL to World Cup _ Walking Wicket (Source_ ©X/Twitter)
T20 WC 2024: Dravid to play a huge role in shifting mindset from IPL (Source: ©X/Twitter)

The introduction of the Impact Player rule in the Indian Premier League (IPL) has fundamentally altered the dynamics of T20 cricket, driving a significant increase in run-scoring. This rule, which allows teams to substitute one player for another at any point during the match, has reshaped the strategies and approaches of teams and players alike.

Surge in run-scoring: A visible impact 

Since its introduction, the Impact Player rule has catalysed an unprecedented surge in scoring rates. The 2024 IPL season, in particular, witnessed an average run rate of 9.58, the highest ever recorded in any T20 series involving more than four matches. This increase underscores the profound influence of the rule on the game, highlighting a change in the mindset of players, who have become more aggressive and now bat without fear of failure.

The rule encourages teams to include more specialists—dedicated batters and bowlers—thus enhancing their capacity to either post or chase down formidable scores. Notably, in IPL 2022, teams averaged 155.52 runs per innings. With the Impact Player rule, this average jumped to 166.65 in 2023 and further to 175.46 in 2024. This escalation illustrates the newfound aggression and freedom with which teams are playing.

For example, Virat Kohli’s performance in IPL 2024 exemplifies this trend. Traditionally known for his consistent but measured approach, Kohli used to operate at a strike rate of 130 to 135. However, in the 2024 season, he unleashed a more aggressive batting style, scoring 741 runs in 15 innings at an average of 61.75 and a strike rate of 154. He also amassed 38 sixes in the season, the second most in any season of the cash-rich league. Kohli’s previous best tally of sixes was 23 in IPL 2015. This showcases how the Impact Player rule has emboldened top-order batters to play more fearlessly.

Challenges posed by the absence of the rule

However, the absence of the Impact Player rule in the T20 WC 2024 presents significant challenges for Team India. The Indian players, coming fresh from the IPL, might struggle to adapt to the traditional format, where the luxury of an additional specialist is unavailable.

Restricted use of all-rounders, lack of part-time bowlers 

The rule has also inadvertently restricted the use of all-rounders, especially in the bowling department. If a player is not a pure four-over bowler, they might not secure a place in the XI. Consequently, to cement their place in the XI, players need to excel in at least one department. For example, players like Shivam Dube, Hardik Pandya and Ravindra Jadeja, who are expected to contribute with both bat and ball, have underperformed and didn’t bowl in every match. 

Dube, despite his explosive batting capabilities, bowled just six deliveries in IPL 2024, taking one wicket at the cost of 14 runs. Similarly, Pandya, returning from injury, managed only 216 runs at an average of 18.00 and a strike rate of 143.05. His bowling figures were equally dismal, conceding 387 runs in 216 balls at an economy rate of 10.75, with only 11 wickets to his name.

Additionally, India lacks the luxury of having part-time bowlers in their top five batters, unlike teams such as Australia, England and New Zealand. Therefore, they rely heavily on Jadeja, Pandya and Dube. Their performances with both bat and ball will be crucial if India are to emerge triumphant after almost 17 years.

Hardik Pandya gets a pat from Rohit Sharma on his best bowling performance in T20I _ Walking Wicket (Courtesy_ ©X/Twitter
Allrounders to play a huge role in T20 WC (Courtesy: ©X/Twitter

The absence of the Impact Player rule means Indian selectors and team management will have to address several critical issues:

1. Balancing the XI: Without the flexibility to swap players mid-match, captain Rohit Sharma and head coach Rahul Dravid will need to meticulously plan their playing XI, ensuring a balanced mix of batters and bowlers.

2. All-rounder Performance: The underperformance of key all-rounders like Pandya and Dube must be addressed. Their dual-role capabilities are crucial in a format that demands versatility.

3. Adapting Strategies: Players will need to recalibrate their strategies to suit the traditional T20 format, where the safety net provided by the Impact Player rule is absent.

4. Mindset Shift: The aggressive mindset fostered by the IPL needs moderation. In international cricket, a more cautious and balanced approach might be necessary, especially in pressure situations.

The Impact Player rule has undeniably revolutionised the IPL, pushing the boundaries of T20 cricket with higher scores and more aggressive playing styles. However, the upcoming T20 World Cup 2024, devoid of this rule, poses a starkly different challenge for Team India. Adapting to the traditional format, managing the form and performance of key players, alongside maintaining a strategic balance will be crucial for India to emerge triumphant on the world stage.


bottom of page